The first order of business in overcoming my Decorating Paralysis is getting two new chairs to replace the ones that are moving to Brooklyn. My hope is to score one secondhand (from the street or a thrift store) then paint/reupholster it, and to purchase the other new and not have to do much to it. Here's what I've found in the latter category, from least to most expensive. The one up top is my favorite!
Now comes the hard part...convincing myself I won't find anything else out there that will be cheaper or that I will like better. Paralyzing, I tell you! :)